What if Whites Were the Minority?
In the responses to my "When Whites Just Don't Get It" series, I've been struck by the lack of empathy some whites show for members of minority groups. So imagine if the world were reversed. Then "the talk" might go like this:
"Son, sit down. You're 13, old enough to have a conversation that I've been dreading."
"Oh, come on, Dad. I hope this isn't about the birds and the bees."
"Nope. That'd be easy. Have you seen the video of the white horticulturalist being choked to death by police?"
"All the kids have seen it. He says he can't breathe, and black cops still kill him. [Expletive!]"
"Don't curse. It is wrong, but it's the way the world works. And that's why Mom and I are scared for you. With us whites in the minority, some cops are just going to see you as a threat no matter what. You're going to get stopped by black cops, and I want you to promise you'll never run or mouth off. Mom and I can't protect you out there, and white kids are 21 times as likely as black kids to be shot dead by police. So even when a cop curses you, I want you to call him Sir."
"Anybody curses me, he won't get away with it."
"Yes, he will. And if he shoots you, he might get away with it, too. Especially when you keep wearing clothes all the other white boys wear like those polo shirts. Black cops see you in them and suspect trouble. Black folks make the rules, and we have to live by them. Like it or not."
"[Expletive!] Racists!"
"Hey! I told you not to curse. And don't hold it against all blacks. Lots have joined with whites in protesting these killings. And even for those who are unsympathetic, most aren't evil, just clueless."
"C'mon, Dad. When a 12-year-old white kid is shot dead because he's holding a toy gun, when a white woman professor is thrown to the ground for jaywalking, when cops smash a car window to taser a white guy in front of kids, that's not cluelessness. That's evil. White lives matter."
"It's complicated. Remember when you were suspended in the fourth grade for being disruptive?"
"That was ridiculous."
What if Whites Were the Minority?
In the responses to my "When Whites Just Don't Get It" series, I've been struck by the lack of empathy some whites show for members of minority groups. So imagine if the world were reversed. Then "the talk" might go like this:
posted by Whitney Tilson at 11:41 AM
<< Home